| Most wins |
| 17 by Wigan |
| Most finals |
| 27 by Wigan |
| Highest score |
| Leeds Rhinos 52 v London Broncos 16 … 1999 (Also widest margin) |
| Lowest winning score |
| Broughton Rangers 4 v Wigan 0 … 1911 |
| Most points aggregate |
| 72 by St. Helens 40 v Bradford Bulls 32 … 1996 |
| Least points aggregate |
| 4 by Broughton Rangers 4 v Wigan 0 … 1911 |
| Most tries by one team |
| 9 by Huddersfield v St. Helens … 1915, Leeds Rhinos v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Consecutive wins and finals |
| 8 by Wigan … 1988-1995 |
| Most tries aggregate |
| 13 by St. Helens (8) v Bradford Bulls (5) … 1996 |
| Biggest attendance |
| 102,569 Warrington v. Halifax (Replay) at Odsal Stadium, Bradford … 1954 |
| Most appearances |
| 11 by Shaun Edwards (Wigan - 1984, 85, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95; London Broncos - 1999) |
| Most wins |
| 9 by Shaun Edwards – as above except 1984 and 1999 |
| Most goals |
| 8 by Cyril Kellett (Featherstone Rovers) v Bradford Northern … 1973, Iestyn Harris (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most tries |
| 4 by Leroy Rivett (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most points |
| 20 (2t, 7g) by Neil Fox (Wakefield) v Hull … 1960, 20 (1t, 8g) by Iestyn Harris (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most goals in all finals |
| 21 by Frano Botica (Wigan) 1991 – 2, 1992 – 5, 1993 – 4, 1994 – 5, 1995 - 5 |
| Most tries in all finals |
| 6 by Kevin Iro (Wigan) 1988 – 2, 1989 – 2, 1990 – 2. Also played for Wigan (1991) and Leeds (1994, 95) without scoring |
| Most points in all finals |
| 46 by Frano Botica (Wigan) 1991 - 8pts, 1992 - 10pts, 1993 – 8pts, 1994 – 10pts, 1995 – 10 pts |
| Highest score |
| Huddersfield 119 v Swinton Park* 2 … 1914 |
| Longest unbeaten run |
| Wigan had a run of 43 unbeaten Cup-ties, including a draw that was followed by 36 wins. Shaun Edwards was the only player to appear in every one. |
*Amateur teams
| Most goals in a match |
| 22 by Jim Sullivan (Wigan) v. Flimby and Fothergill* … 1925 |
| Most tries in a match |
| 11 by George West (Hull Kingston Rovers) v. Brookland Rovers* … 1905 |
| Most points in a match |
| 53 (11t, 10g) by George West (Hull Kingston Rovers) as above. |
| Most wins |
| 15 by Wigan |
| Most finals |
| 22 by Wigan |
| Highest score |
| Leeds Rhinos 52 v London Broncos 16 … 1999 (Also widest margin) |
| Lowest winning score |
| Salford 7 v Barrow 4 … 1938 Castleford 7 v Wigan 2 … 1970 |
| Most points aggregate |
| 72 by St. Helens 40 v Bradford Bulls 32 … 1996 |
| Least points aggregate |
| 8 by Halifax (4) v Warrington (4) … 1954 |
| Most tries by one team |
| 9 by Leeds Rhinos v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most tries aggregate |
| 13 by St. Helens (8) v Bradford Bulls (5) … 1996 |
| Consecutive wins and finals |
| 8 by Wigan … 1988-1995 |
| Biggest attendance |
| 99,801 Hull v Wigan... 1985 |
| Most appearances |
| 11 by Shaun Edwards (Wigan - 1984, 85, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95; London Broncos - 1999) |
| Most wins |
| 9 by Shaun Edwards – as above except 1984 and 1999 |
| Most goals |
| 8 by Cyril Kellett (Featherstone Rovers) v Bradford Northern … 1973 Iestyn Harris (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most tries |
| 4 by Leroy Rivett (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most points |
| 20 (2t, 7g) by Neil Fox (Wakefield) v Hull … 1960 20 (1t, 8g) by Iestyn Harris (Leeds Rhinos) v London Broncos … 1999 |
| Most goals in all finals |
| 21 by Frano Botica (Wigan) 1991 – 2, 1992 – 5, 1993 – 4, 1994 – 5, 1995 - 5 |
| Most tries in all finals |
| 6 by Kevin Iro (Wigan) 1988 – 2, 1989 – 2, 1990 – 2. Also played for Wigan (1991) and Leeds (1994, 95) without scoring |
| Most points in all finals |
| 46 by Frano Botica (Wigan) 1991 - 8pts, 1992 - 10pts, 1993 – 8pts, 1994 – 10pts, 1995 – 10 pts |